top of page

Insights

Is Profit The Goal Or The Result?

By

Dov Shenkman

"The purpose of business is to create and keep a customer." — Peter Drucker


It's a simple idea. Almost too simple and may seem obvious—after all, who else buys the stuff? But it's surprising how many companies, even successful ones, get it backwards. The starting point of any business is not the product, not the quarterly profit, and definitely not the org chart. It's the customer!

Profit is not the goal—it's a result. The real goal is to deliver differentiated value to the customer. Do that right, and the rest follows. A course reset for businesses that had started thinking of profit as the destination, not the outcome. For leaders who spent more time optimizing spreadsheets than listening to real customers. For companies that forgot why they existed in the first place.

Most businesses proudly declare their mission: to be #1 in their category, to "unlock shareholder value," to revolutionize an industry. Ambitious goals—sure. But they're often internally focused. Your reason for existing shouldn't start with what you want. It should start with what the customer needs.

However, knowing that the customer is the business and actually organizing your planning processes around customer value are two different challenges. Most organizations struggle to translate customer insights into coordinated action across functions like product development, demand planning, supply chain, and financial planning. Marketing might understand customer needs perfectly while supply chain optimizes for cost efficiency without considering customer impact. Sales might build strong relationships while operations prioritizes internal metrics over customer experience.

This is where Value-Centric Integrated Business Planning becomes essential—transforming customer understanding into systematic planning processes that align every function around customer value creation.


You Are What Your Customer Hires You to Do

A business is not defined by the company's name, statutes, or articles of incorporation. It is defined by the value the customer realizes when they buy a product or a service. You are what your customers hire you to do. You can manufacture shoes, but your customer may be buying style. You can build software, but they're paying for simplicity. You can sell insurance, but what they really want is peace of mind.

Let's take a simple example. A hardware store might think it sells power drills. But the customer doesn't want a drill—they want a hole in the wall. Or more specifically, they want to hang a family photo. And really, they want to feel something every time they pass by it.

The drill is just a means to that end.

This hardware store example illustrates a crucial concept we'll explore throughout this book: customers "hire" your product or service to do a specific job. Understanding these jobs-to-be-done becomes the foundation for all planning decisions—from product development priorities to inventory allocation to customer service design. When a customer hires your solution, they're trying to make progress in their life or business. Your planning processes must ensure that every function contributes to that progress rather than optimizing for internal convenience.

If your business gets stuck thinking only about what it offers, you'll miss the bigger opportunity: to solve the real problem your customer is trying to fix. That mindset unlocks better product design, better messaging, and better loyalty. More importantly, it provides the North Star that aligns all your planning processes around creating genuine customer value.

The purpose of a business starts on the outside from the customer and works its way in because a business only exists for one reason: because someone is willing to pay for what it offers. That's it. No customer, no business. Not even a clever one. Peter Drucker put it simply: "It is the customer who determines what a business is... because it is the customer who pays."

You might call yourself a tech company, but if customers are coming to you for service, not features—you're in the service business. You might think you sell luxury, but if your buyer is looking for practicality, you're in a very different game. Understanding your customer isn't a task. It's a mindset that must permeate every planning decision and resource allocation choice your organization makes.


The Evidence: Stakeholder Value Drives Financial Returns

Strategy has traditionally been seen as a competition-focused discipline—a zero-sum game where winners take market share and optimize profit. But in today's stakeholder economy, that view is no longer sufficient. Strategy must now be viewed as the art and science of allocating resources to create value not only for shareholders, but also for the broader ecosystem: customers, employees, suppliers, and communities.

In July 2024, in a comprehensive study by Bain & Company, researchers analyzed 4,228 companies across eight industries over a 10-year period. They assessed which companies excelled at delivering stakeholder value—measured through customer satisfaction, employee engagement, supplier relationships, and community impact—and which delivered the strongest financial returns.

The results were compelling: companies that outperformed on both dimensions of value creation—stakeholder and financial—consistently generated the highest shareholder returns. These firms didn't just balance interests; they aligned them, turning stakeholder trust into sustainable growth.

The Bain study revealed that while technology delivered the highest average shareholder returns across industries, that's only part of the story. In every industry, the top 10% of companies outperformed the average returns of tech firms. Being in a "hot" or high-growth industry doesn't guarantee superior performance. What truly matters is how well a company aligns its capabilities and value model to stakeholder needs within its chosen context.

The Bain analysis empirically reinforces that stakeholder value, particularly customer satisfaction and loyalty, directly correlates with long-term financial performance. High-performing firms who consistently invest in understanding and delivering superior customer value benefited from repeat business, higher pricing power, and brand advocacy—all of which translated into revenue growth and margin improvement.

The study helps resolve the old debate: shareholder vs. stakeholder. The answer is both—and the best strategies are those that align their ambitions. In a world where stakeholder metrics are measurable and actionable, competitive advantage goes to the companies that build stakeholder trust into the core of their planning, execution, and performance measurement.

This research validates what we'll explore throughout this book: customer-centric planning isn't just the right thing to do morally—it's the most effective strategy for sustainable competitive advantage and financial performance.


The Planning Challenge: From Understanding to Action

Not all customers are the same, and not all customers provide equal value to your business. Some customers may love what you do but provide limited business returns, while others may generate significant revenue but perceive limited value in your offering. Some customers expand their relationships over time while others remain static despite high satisfaction. Understanding these dynamics—and planning accordingly—requires sophisticated approaches that balance customer value creation with business value capture.

Traditional business planning often optimizes for internal metrics—forecast accuracy, cost efficiency, operational coordination. While these remain important, they're no longer sufficient. Modern planning must optimize for customer outcomes while maintaining operational excellence. This requires planning processes that can segment customers by value potential, predict behavior changes, and coordinate responses across all functions.

The challenge becomes even more complex in today's digital environment. Customer expectations have been shaped by digital leaders like Amazon and Apple. Customers expect personalized, responsive, and proactive experiences that require sophisticated technology capabilities and real-time coordination across multiple systems and functions. However, technology alone isn't enough—it must be guided by genuine customer insight and coordinated planning that ensures all organizational activities contribute to customer value creation.


The Pattern Behind Success

Successful companies didn't succeed by simply improving what already existed. They succeeded because they exemplify the stakeholder-financial value alignment that the Bain research identified as the key to sustainable competitive advantage.

They succeeded because they:

  • Started with the customer's point of view, not internal capabilities

  • Identified what customers really valued, not just what they said they wanted

  • Aligned their entire business—strategy, operations, and planning—to deliver that  value consistently across all touchpoints

  • Built planning processes that coordinated multiple functions around customer outcomes rather than functional optimization

  • Created integrated systems that could adapt and respond to changing customer needs while maintaining operational excellence

It's not just innovation—it's empathetic innovation guided by systematic planning. The only kind that matters in today's competitive environment.


Building Customer-Centric Planning Capabilities

It’s time for Value Centric Integrated Business Planning that incorporates this customer-centric mindset into every aspect of your business planning:

  • Define value through your customer's eyes and segment customers based on your and cusitomer value potential rather than just demographics

  • Measure what matters most to them through comprehensive customer and buisness value frameworks

  • Create integrated planning processes that turn customer insight into competitive advantage across product development, demand planning, supply chain, and   financial planning

  • Build organizational capabilities that support customer value creation while  maintaining operational excellence

  • Leverage technology and AI to scale customer understanding and response capabilities

  • Develop cultures that naturally prioritize customer outcomes in daily decisions

  • Transform traditional planning processes into value-centric systems that create sustainable competitive advantages

The transformation from traditional business planning to Value-Centric Integrated Business Planning isn't just about understanding customers better—it's about building systematic capabilities that ensure customer understanding influences every decision, every plan, and every action your organization takes. When done effectively, this transformation creates the sustainable competitive advantages that drive both stakeholder satisfaction and financial performance, just as the Bain study demonstrated.

Let's begin that transformation.

bottom of page